ActiveState Community

"Save Remotely As" vs "Upload"

Posted by wolfe on 2007-07-09 11:16
OS: All / Any

I've been trying out Komodo for a few days and one thing keeps bugging me. The only way that I've found to transfer my work to the server is to use the "Save Remotely As..." function. Then as I continue to work, Komodo is making changes to the remote copy of the file without updating the local copy. When I close out Komodo and return to the local file later it is out of date.

What I'd like to see is a way to continue saving all work-in-progress changes to the local file and then allow me to upload the file as I need to. Am I missing something in Komodo that will allow me to do this?

I'm in a single developer environment and don't see the need to complicate things by going to CVS. And I'm not sure that would change anything about this issue anyway.

shanec | Mon, 2007-07-09 11:41

You might want to look into using rsync, there is an article about it here: http://community.activestate.com/faq/using-rsync-with-projects

wrightee | Wed, 2008-01-02 09:00

I'm used to using NuSphere which allows associating a server / upload path with a project for remote publishing. Being able to either right click on a file and select upload or Ctrl+Shift+S to save remotely is one of the best things I've found in an IDE for working speed.

I normally use a SVN repos for collab and a test server or two, exporting directly from the repository to the live installation and ftp uploading to the test server only, so rsync won't work for us.

toddw | Wed, 2008-01-02 13:29

Just to let you know that we are looking into adding this feature to Komodo, though I cannot yet give an estimated arrival date.

The remote file API's are there for the impatient, if someone wishes to make an extension to support this, you can take a look at the remote drive tree extension for ideas:
http://community.activestate.com/komodo-extension/remote-drive-tree

Cheers,
Todd

grubolsch | Tue, 2008-04-22 13:49

Whould be great to see that implemented!

loubabe | Wed, 2008-11-05 16:40

This seems like a critical feature, at least for those of us who need to deploy our local files via FTP. Opening up a separate FTP client, finding the right file, etc. is extremely cumbersome.

Fire | Sun, 2009-01-25 08:25

Hi there, I too am a NuSphere user, however, id like to switch to komodo because of it's toolset featuer and native operation on a mac....

the only thing that is stopping me is the fact that I cant ftp it by pressing cntrol-shift-s just like nusphere.

The reason why I am not using svn to do this is because the project is a branch from svn, but I upload to my own server, before committing to the project, thus, a separate ftp is needed, and only svn when committing.

i hope this feature is added soon - komodo looks pretty rockin

sjferwerda | Fri, 2009-02-06 23:45

I have friends who have refused to purchase Komodo or upgrade because of the lack of a decent remote file management addon/feature.

As one poster mentioned above, if creating the addon is so easy why doesn't AC either:

1. Create their own addon.

2. Hire a Firefox addons developer to create on for a few thousand dollars.

I'm sure the cost you'd pay for hiring someone would easily be made up for by all of the people that try Komodo but don't purchase because of a lack this feature.

I realize that you are not trying to be all things to all people, and that is good...but it really appears from all of the posts on this forum that there is a real and valid need for this.

joeycalamaro | Thu, 2009-10-15 08:14

I just started testing Komodo and honestly up until now I assumed this feature was built in and I just could find it. Has it been resolved yet? I have little interest in using Komodo if I can't publish or sync my files via FTP.

toddw | Thu, 2009-10-15 10:56

There are no remote file sync features in Komodo - the remote file capabilities of Komodo are designed to edit the remote files directly.

Cheers,
Todd

joeycalamaro | Fri, 2009-10-16 11:15

Well there goes that. For what it's worth Komodo is otherwise a very nice editor. But without the ability to publish my work I won't be able to use it. Oh well. :-(